Why the costing method you choose changes your profit
When you buy the same product at different prices over time - which almost every business does, as supplier costs rise and fall - and then sell some of it, you have to decide which of those purchase costs you’re actually reporting as the cost of what you sold. That decision is the costing method, and it directly changes your reported Cost of Goods Sold, your gross profit, and (in most jurisdictions) your taxable income - from the exact same physical purchases and sales.
Worked example: same purchases, different profit
You buy 100 units at $10, then 100 more at $12 (prices rose). You sell 100 units for $20 each. Under FIFO, the 100 units sold are costed at $10 (the oldest batch), giving $1,000 COGS and $1,000 gross profit. Under weighted average, the blended cost is $11/unit, giving $1,100 COGS and $900 gross profit. Same units bought, same units sold, same sale price - different reported profit.
FIFO: First In, First Out
FIFO assumes the oldest inventory in stock is the first to be sold - which also happens to match the physical flow of most real businesses, especially anyone selling perishable or dated goods. In a period of rising prices, FIFO reports lower Cost of Goods Sold (older, cheaper stock is expensed first) and therefore higher gross profit and higher taxable income than the alternatives.
Weighted Average Cost
Weighted average cost blends all available inventory into a single average cost per unit, recalculated as new stock comes in. It’s well suited to businesses where individual units of the same product are genuinely interchangeable (you can’t tell which batch a specific unit came from), and it smooths out cost fluctuations rather than reporting them sharply the way FIFO can.
Standard Costing
Standard costing assigns a predetermined, fixed cost to each item - set in advance and held constant until you deliberately revise it (typically on a quarterly or annual review) - regardless of what you actually paid on any individual purchase. The difference between the standard cost and what you actually paid is tracked separately as a purchase price variance, which is reviewed on its own rather than distorting the day-to-day cost of goods figure.
| Method | Best suited to | Effect when prices are rising |
|---|---|---|
| FIFO | Perishable or dated goods, businesses that want cost flow to match physical flow | Lower COGS, higher reported profit |
| Weighted average | Interchangeable/commodity-style inventory, frequent price fluctuation | A blended, smoothed effect between the extremes |
| Standard cost | Manufacturers with predictable, planned production costs | No immediate effect - variance is tracked and reviewed separately |
Choosing between the three methods
LIFO: why most of the world can’t use it
Last In, First Out (LIFO) assumes the newest inventory is sold first - the opposite of FIFO. It’s permitted under US GAAP, where some businesses use it specifically because it reduces reported profit (and therefore tax) during periods of rising prices. It is explicitly prohibited under IFRS, the standard used across most of the world outside the US, which is why most international guides mention it only for completeness rather than as a real option.
Check what your local rules actually allow
Which costing methods are permitted for tax reporting varies by country - always confirm with a local accountant before choosing, especially if you operate across more than one jurisdiction.
Lot and expiry tracking: a related but different problem
Costing method (how you value what you sold) is a separate question from lot, serial, and expiry tracking (which specific physical units you sold, and whether older or soon-to-expire stock gets prioritized - often called FEFO, First Expired First Out, for perishable goods). A business can use FIFO costing while also tracking individual lots with expiry dates for compliance or quality reasons - the two systems work together, not as substitutes for each other.
Switching methods: what to know before you do
Changing costing methods isn’t just a settings toggle - it changes reported historical figures and, in many jurisdictions, has real tax and disclosure implications. Talk to your accountant before switching, and expect to document the reason for the change.
Which costing method is "most accurate"?
None is universally more accurate - each is a different, legitimate way of allocating real costs. The right choice depends on your industry, how your inventory actually behaves, and what your local accounting standard requires or permits.
Does the costing method affect my actual cash flow?
No - the cash you actually paid suppliers doesn’t change. Costing method only changes how that spend is allocated between "cost of what I sold" and "value of what I still hold," which affects reported profit and tax, not the underlying cash.
Can I use different costing methods for different product lines?
In many jurisdictions, yes, as long as it’s applied consistently within each category and properly disclosed - but this varies by local standard, so confirm with your accountant before mixing methods.
The inventory didn’t change. The story you’re allowed to tell about its cost did.
Resources
Was this guide helpful?